When an employee is suspected of violating company policy, engaging in misconduct, or exhibiting inappropriate behavior, a human resources (HR) investigation is often necessary. An HR investigation can help the company gather information and evidence, make informed decisions, and take appropriate action.

However, conducting an HR investigation can be a complex and sensitive process, and it's important to approach it with care and professionalism. One of the most critical components of an HR investigation is asking the right questions.

In this blog, we'll explore the key questions to ask during an HR investigation, how to ask them, and why they're important. Whether you're an HR professional, a manager, or an employee, understanding the investigation process and the role of questions can help ensure a fair and thorough investigation.

Why asking the right questions matter in an HR investigation

Asking the right questions is critical in an HR investigation to ensure that the investigation is conducted thoroughly, fairly, and in accordance with legal and ethical standards. Here's why asking the right questions is important:

Gathering accurate information: The right questions can help ensure that accurate and relevant information is collected during the investigation. This information can then be used to make informed decisions about the alleged misconduct or violation.

Objectivity and fairness: Asking the right questions can help ensure that the investigation is conducted in an objective and fair manner. By asking open-ended questions that allow the respondent to provide their version of events or perspective, investigators can avoid leading the witness or biasing their responses.

Efficient use of time: By asking targeted questions, the investigator can avoid spending time on irrelevant or unimportant information. This can help streamline the investigation process and prevent it from becoming overly time-consuming or burdensome.

Ensuring legal compliance: Asking the right questions can help ensure that the investigation is conducted in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. For example, questions should be designed to avoid discriminatory or harassing behavior towards the respondent, as well as to protect the privacy of all parties involved.

Questioning The Reporter of an HR Investigation

Questioning the reporter of an HR investigation is an important first step in the investigative process. The reporter is typically the person who brought the issue to the attention of the company or HR department, and their initial report will often serve as the basis for the investigation.

When questioning the reporter, it's important to start by establishing a rapport and creating a safe space for them to share their concerns. Here are some key questions to consider asking:

• What happened? Ask the reporter to describe the incident or behavior they observed or experienced. Encourage them to be as specific as possible, and avoid interrupting or leading the witness.
• When did this happen? Ask the reporter to provide a timeline of events, including the date, time, and location of the incident or behavior.
• Who was involved? Ask the reporter to identify any individuals who were involved in the incident or behavior. If they are unsure of someone's name or job title, ask for a description of the person or their role.
• Were there any witnesses? Ask the reporter if there were any witnesses to the incident or behavior, and if so, ask for their contact information. This can help you gather additional information and corroborate the reporter's account.
• How did the incident or behavior affect you? Ask the reporter to describe how the incident or behavior impacted them, both personally and professionally. This can help you understand the severity of the situation and the potential impact on the company.

It's important to remember that questioning the reporter is just the first step in the investigative process. Additional interviews with the alleged perpetrator and any witnesses may also be necessary to gather all of the relevant information and reach a fair and impartial conclusion.

20 examples of questions to ask the reporter of an HR investigation

Need more examples of questions to ask? The following questions can help you gather important information about the incident and the individuals involved. It's important to ask open-ended questions and avoid leading the witness or making assumptions about the situation. Here are 20 examples of questions to ask a reporter during

1. Can you describe what happened in your own words?
2. When and where did the incident occur?
3. Who else was present during the incident?
4. Can you provide any documentation or evidence related to the incident?
5. Were there any statements or actions that made you feel uncomfortable or unsafe?
6. Did anyone else witness the incident? If so, can you provide their contact information?
7. Have you experienced any similar incidents in the past?
8. Have you spoken to anyone else about the incident? If so, who and what was discussed?
9. Did you feel comfortable reporting the incident to your supervisor or HR? If not, why?
10. Can you describe the impact the incident has had on you, both personally and professionally?
11. Is there anything that you did that may have contributed to the incident?
12. Is there anything that you did not do that you feel could have prevented the incident?
13. Are there any other incidents or interactions that may be relevant to the current situation?
14. Did you try to resolve the issue with the other party before reporting it to HR?
15. Were there any other incidents or behaviors leading up to the current situation that might have contributed to the incident?
16. Did anyone make any comments that you feel were discriminatory, harassing, or retaliatory?
17. Is there anything else you would like to share about the incident or the individuals involved?
18. Do you have any concerns or fears related to the investigation or any potential actions that might be taken?
19. Do you feel that you are being treated fairly and respectfully during the investigation process?
20. Is there anything else that you feel is important for the investigator to know?

Remember that these questions should be tailored to the specific situation and individual involved, and should be asked in a respectful and supportive manner. The goal is to gather information and ensure that the investigation is conducted fairly and impartially.

Questioning The Witness in an HR Investigation

Questioning a witness during an HR investigation is an important step in gathering information and understanding the incident from multiple perspectives. Here are some tips on how to question a witness effectively:

• Establish a rapport: Start by introducing yourself and explaining the purpose of the investigation. Make sure the witness is comfortable and has a clear understanding of the process.
• Ask open-ended questions: Avoid leading questions and focus on asking open-ended questions that allow the witness to provide detailed information.
• Listen actively: Listen carefully to the witness's responses and ask follow-up questions to clarify or expand on their statements.
• Be respectful: Show respect for the witness and their perspective, even if their version of events differs from the reporter's.
• Keep the interview confidential: Let the witness know that their interview is confidential, and that they should not discuss the details of the investigation with anyone else.
• Take detailed notes: Record the witness's responses in as much detail as possible, including any relevant dates, times, locations, and individuals involved.
• Thank the witness: Thank the witness for their time and willingness to provide information.

15 examples of questions to ask the witness of an HR investigation

Remember, the goal of questioning a witness is to gather information and understand the incident from multiple perspectives. By asking thoughtful and open-ended questions, you can help ensure that the investigation is conducted fairly and impartially. Here are some examples of questions to ask the witness:

1. Can you describe what you observed during the incident?
2. When and where did the incident occur?
3. Who else was present during the incident?
4. Did you hear anything that was said during the incident?
5. Was anyone's behavior or actions particularly concerning or alarming?
6. Did anyone seem upset or uncomfortable during the incident?
7. Have you observed any similar behavior in the past?
8. Did you witness any actions or behavior leading up to the incident that might be relevant?
9. Can you describe any conversations or interactions that you had with the individuals involved before or after the incident?
10. Were there any other witnesses to the incident? If so, can you provide their contact information?
11. Did anyone make any comments that you feel were discriminatory, harassing, or retaliatory?
12. Is there anything else that you think is important for the investigator to know?
13. How did you feel about what you witnessed during the incident?
14. Did you feel comfortable reporting what you witnessed to HR or your supervisor? If not, why?
15. Is there anything else you would like to add or clarify about what you witnessed during the incident?

Remember to approach the witness with respect and sensitivity, and to ask open-ended questions that allow them to share their observations and perspectives.

Questioning the accused party in an HR investigation

Questioning the accused party in an HR investigation is an important step in gathering all sides of the story and understanding the incident from multiple perspectives. It's essential to approach this process in a professional and impartial manner to ensure a fair investigation. Here are some tips on how to question the accused party effectively:

• Explain the purpose of the interview: Start by introducing yourself and explaining the purpose of the interview. Make it clear that this is part of an investigation and that their participation is necessary to ensure a fair and thorough investigation.
• Ask open-ended questions: Ask open-ended questions that allow the accused party to provide detailed information about their perspective on the incident.
• Listen actively: Listen carefully to their responses and ask follow-up questions to clarify or expand on their statements.
• Be respectful: Treat the accused party with respect and avoid making assumptions or accusations.
• Give them an opportunity to respond: Give them a chance to respond to any allegations made against them.
• Provide relevant evidence: Provide the accused party with any relevant evidence, such as witness statements or documentation, and ask for their response.
• Remind them of confidentiality: Remind the accused party that the interview is confidential and that they should not discuss the details of the investigation with anyone else.
• Take detailed notes: Record their responses in as much detail as possible, including any relevant dates, times, locations, and individuals involved.
• Thank them: Thank the accused party for their time and willingness to participate in the investigation.

20 examples of questions to ask the accused party of an HR investigation

Questioning the accused member in an HR investigation is a crucial step in the process of gathering all sides of the story and understanding the incident from multiple perspectives. It is essential to approach this process in a professional and impartial manner to ensure a fair investigation. The way you frame your questions and conduct the interview can have a significant impact on the quality and reliability of the information obtained.

1. Can you describe your perspective on what happened during the incident?
2. When and where did the incident occur, and who was present?
3. What was your behavior or actions during the incident?
4. Did you notice any behavior or statements from others that made you uncomfortable or concerned?
5. Can you describe any conversations or interactions that you had with the other parties involved before or after the incident?
6. Did you have any motive or reason to behave in a certain way during the incident?
7. Have you had any similar incidents or complaints made against you in the past?
8. Are there any witnesses or evidence that you would like to bring to our attention?
9. Is there anything else that you think is important for us to know?
10. Can you explain the events leading up to the incident?
11. Did you feel like your actions were justified? Why or why not?
12. Did you feel uncomfortable or threatened during the incident? If so, how did you respond?
13. Did you feel like you were treated fairly and respectfully by the other parties involved?
14. Did you have any concerns or complaints about the behavior of the other parties involved?
15. Did you follow company policies and procedures during the incident? If not, why?
16. Did you have any knowledge of company policies and procedures regarding the behavior in question prior to the incident?
17. Did you receive any training or guidance on how to handle similar situations?
18. Have you been in contact with any of the other parties involved since the incident?
19. Did you discuss the incident with anyone else? If so, who?
20. Is there anything else you would like to add or clarify about the incident or your behavior during the incident?

Remember to approach the accused member with respect and professionalism, and to ask open-ended questions that allow them to provide detailed information about their perspective on the incident. The goal is to gather as much information as possible to make an informed decision about how to proceed with the investigation.

Dos and don’ts for questioning all parties

Certainly, here are some general dos and don'ts to keep in mind when questioning all parties involved in an HR investigation:

Dos:

• Approach all parties with respect and professionalism, and make them feel comfortable and safe to share their perspective.
• Use open-ended questions that allow for detailed and thorough answers.
• Listen actively and give the interviewee enough time to respond to your questions.
• Take detailed notes and record the interview with the interviewee's consent, so that you can refer back to the information later.
• Keep an open mind and remain objective throughout the investigation.
• Follow up with the parties involved to gather more information or clarify any details that were not clear.
• Be empathetic and considerate of the emotional impact that the incident may have had on the parties involved.
• Stay neutral and avoid making assumptions or drawing conclusions before completing the investigation.

Don'ts:

• Don't rush the interview or interrupt the interviewee.
• Don't use leading questions that may influence the interviewee's answers.
• Don't make promises or assurances that cannot be kept.
• Don't engage in confrontational or aggressive behavior.
• Don't discuss the details of the investigation with anyone who is not directly involved in the investigation.
• Don't make assumptions or judgments based on personal biases or stereotypes.
• Don't disclose the identity of the reporter or the witnesses without their consent.
• Don't disclose the details of the investigation until it is complete.

By following these dos and don'ts, you can conduct a fair and impartial investigation that gathers all the relevant information necessary to make informed decisions.

How to assess credibility in an investigation

Assessing credibility is a crucial step in conducting a fair and impartial investigation. Here are some key factors to consider when evaluating the credibility of individuals involved in an investigation:

Consistency: Are the statements of the individual consistent with other evidence, statements, and documentation collected during the investigation?

Plausibility: Does the individual's version of events make logical sense given the other information gathered?

Corroboration: Are there any other witnesses or pieces of evidence that support the individual's version of events?

Bias: Does the individual have a personal interest or motive in the outcome of the investigation that may impact their credibility?

Demeanor: Did the individual appear to be truthful and cooperative during the investigation? Were there any indications of deception or evasiveness?

Reputation: Does the individual have a history of dishonesty, unethical behavior, or other credibility issues that may impact their credibility in this investigation?

Documentation: Are there any documents or records that support or contradict the individual's statements?

Experience: Does the individual have relevant expertise or experience that would lend credibility to their statements?

It's important to approach the evaluation of credibility objectively and without bias. Consider all relevant factors and weigh the evidence carefully before making a determination of credibility. Remember to document your assessments and the reasoning behind your conclusions in the investigation report. Ultimately, the goal is to arrive at a fair and impartial determination of what occurred and what actions, if any, are necessary to address the situation.

Have the best tool for HR Investigations

Allvoices is an innovative workplace investigations management platform that allows employees to report incidents anonymously, with customizable workflows that enable HR teams to handle investigations with ease. Allvoices uses data to drive insights and supports organizations to address issues such as harassment, discrimination, and retaliation.